Facebook and the Illusion of Intimacy

by Dan Tynan

When word got out that my wife and I were splitting up, I received several emails from long-time friends who knew us back when we were both skinny–err, dating.

“I am a little heartbroken about your current relationship status,” wrote one.

“What’s with the single status? Are you guys splitsky? That’s so wrong and sad,” wrote another.

The thing is, we never actually told anyone we were divorcing. Because, in fact, we weren’t.

All we’d done was change our Facebook relationship status from “Married” to “It’s complicated” and then to “Single.” It was an experiment in social networking; we wanted to see what would happen. Would anyone notice? Would they care? Would some long-lost flame suddenly re-emerge to declare he was still carrying a torch, lo these many decades? (That was my wife’s part of the experiment, in case you’re wondering.)

But after the first few emails came in, we couldn’t resist having a little fun. So I used my Facebook status updates to elaborate about my upcoming (fictional) move to Seattle, while my wife went on about all the fascinating men she was meeting on eHarmony. (Which isn’t fictional, but that’s a story for anther time.)

More emails arrived.

“How are the kids handling it?” one concerned friend wrote.

“Oh, as best as can be expected,” I replied.

Are we evil? Probably.

Aside from being a really kick-ass April Fools Day joke, though, our experiment taught me a few things about how social media is changing, and how it’s changing us.

Unlike many of our old friends (at least, those who are still speaking to us), we no longer live in a high-tech Mecca. When we tell our local friends about Facebook, we have to explain what it is and why anyone would use it. We say that Facebook and other social networks offer the illusion of intimacy – the feeling that you’re in someone’s life, even if you’re not.

But now I’m not so sure that’s true. Because being “intimate” with someone – in a non-clothing-optional way – usually means being caught up on the plot, tuned into the mini-dramas that play out in other people’s lives. Facebook has that kind of intimacy in spades.

My Facebook network is a strange melange of friends and relatives I’ve known all my life, people I worked with long ago but don’t see much any more, and near total strangers I couldn’t pick out of a police lineup. Yet simply by reading their status updates, I know more about some of them than I’d ever have gleaned through normal day-to-day interaction.

I learned, for example, that a PR professional I met once 15 years ago not only hails from my hometown but is also shagging the editor of a magazine I write for. Meanwhile, said editor obsessively updates his own Facebook status, so I know where he is on an almost hourly basis.

A fellow freelancer recently complained to me that this editor never returns his emails. “Oh,” I said, “That’s because he’s currently in Germany, and then in New York for a conference. He’ll be back next Tuesday. You should drop him a note on Facebook; he always replies to those.”

I’ve learned one person I was convinced is gay is in fact married with two kids and worries a lot about his lawn. I know which of my Facebook friends is dangerously obsessed with baseball and which ones can’t stop posting strange videos to YouTube when they really should be working. I know what my Facebook friends had for breakfast, who’s hungover, who’s in the middle of buying a house, and how grandma’s hip surgery turned out. And that’s just today’s updates.

I feel strangely closer to these people, even though I’m viewing them through the lens of a telegraphic note broadcast to an unknown number of strangers.

It’s cool. It’s also weird. But mainly it’s cool.

Overall, I’d call our experiment a moderate success. On the positive side, we didn’t receive any “Woo-hoo – glad you finally dumped that loser!” responses. (At least, I didn’t. I can’t speak for my wife.) While we didn’t get as many condolences or mash notes as we would have liked, it’s nice to know somebody still cares.

As for us, we’re doing just fine, thanks. Most of the time things are pretty great, and the rest of the time … well, there’s a reason we don’t keep firearms in the house. That’s just the way it is when you’ve been married for 347 years.

But if we do get divorced, you’ll be the first to know. After I’ve told everyone on Facebook, of course.

Technorati Tags: ,,,,,

This material is protected by a Creative Commons license. Feel free to share, but don’t steal it, change it, or claim it as your own or I will get medieval on your assets.

8 Responses to “Facebook and the Illusion of Intimacy”

  1. on 21 Apr 2008 at 9:58 pm you know who

    you are evil. truly ;)

  2. on 21 Apr 2008 at 10:30 pm Jerry Levine

    You are a tool. I hope your friends dump you for fucking with them like that.

  3. on 22 Apr 2008 at 4:38 am admin

    well I guess I won’t be adding jerry to my facebook friends list. – dt

  4. on 22 Apr 2008 at 11:20 am Brooke

    You changed your status from “married” to “it’s complicated” on March 11, and from “it’s complicated” to “single” on April 17. How is that an April Fool’s joke? I sent you a note of condolence on March 12, and didn’t hear otherwise until now — about a month and a half later. Maybe next you should write an article on social media etiquette.

  5. on 22 Apr 2008 at 12:01 pm admin

    my apologies to anyone we pissed off with our experiment. but really, I think you’re taking it all too seriously.

  6. on 22 Apr 2008 at 12:29 pm Carl

    my apologies to anyone we pissed off with our experiment. but really, I think you’re taking it all too seriously.

    Now, Dan, it’s not proper to cancel out your apology with a condition! Anyway, I think you’re just surprised by how much folks care.

    Personally, I find it quite clever, but can see why your friends would be just a bit hacked. I have several who would kill me.

  7. on 23 Apr 2008 at 6:35 pm Ray Nash

    Mr, Tynan,

    It sounds like you didn’t learn from your own experiment. The fact that your friends contacted you with concern shows that Facebook is a sincere form of communication, as sincere as letters or email or phone calls. There are many kinds and methods of human communication, and social media is an ever-stronger form that only continues to gain popularity. While you may disdain it, many millions of people use it to keep in touch — honestly and sincerely — with friends and acquaintences. It seems like you, by not taking Facebook seriously, are actually the one who doesn’t “get it”, not your friends who you think need to lighten up.

  8. on 24 Apr 2008 at 12:11 pm rl

    Yes, I agree…you are evil. I also agree: marriage and firearms? Bad combo. We use Silly String to resolve disputes. That, and Excessive Pouting.

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply